Why is there a rise of violence in Canadian public libraries?


Click to play video: 'The rise of violence in Canada’s public libraries'


The rise of violence in Canada’s public libraries


The random acts of violence which might be taking place on our streets and in our transit programs in cities throughout Canada are additionally making their approach into public libraries.

Native branches of all sizes are reporting a rise in verbal and bodily violence. And for some, the pandemic made it even worse.

Over the previous two years, one particular person died and 6 others had been injured in a mass stabbing in a public library in North Vancouver. Final December, 28-year-old Tyree Cayer was killed throughout a go to to Winnipeg’s Millennium Library. 4 youngsters had been charged in his demise. And two branches of the Saskatoon library had been closed quickly due to considerations about workers security.

Learn extra:

Calgary police obtain leads on suspect in Central Library senior assault

Cameron Ray, a supervisor librarian with Toronto Public Library, stated he has lived the expertise first hand — and several other occasions.

“I did have one yr the place each three months I used to be assaulted. This man chased me across the department with a pair of hair scissors, like, ‘I’m going to stab you,’” he says. “That was terrifying.”

Ray and colleague Eila McLeish met once they labored collectively on the Toronto Reference Library. McLeish has been screamed at, sworn at, and even stalked by a disgruntled patron.

“I’ve come throughout overdose victims, people who find themselves unconscious.”

McLeish got here throughout a lifeless physique in a library washroom. “That was fairly horrible,” she provides.

McLeish modified to a smaller department, however she says it obtained worse. She has obtained counselling and was on sick go away for a yr earlier than returning to work in April.


Librarians Cameron Ray and Eila McLeish share their experiences with violent incidents in public libraries.


Brent Rose/International Information

Consultants say libraries are a mirrored image of the world round them. And society’s issues are discovering their approach inside their doorways.

“Individuals are coming into the library they usually have actually vital wants,” says Siobhan Stevenson, a professor with the School of Data on the College of Toronto.

“There are every kind of social crises, humanitarian crises, in our cities: homelessness, the opioid epidemic, random acts of violence … a social security internet that’s been so diminished,” she instructed International Information’ The New Actuality.


Siobhan Stevenson a professor on the College of Toronto, has studied the altering position of public libraries.


Brent Rose/International Information

That’s left many individuals with advanced wants with usually nowhere to go for assist. Public libraries, by their very nature, are dedicated to being welcoming and inclusive.

“People come to our areas as a result of they really feel that it’s a secure place that they’ll come into,”
says Brian Daly, chief human sources officer on the Toronto Public Library, the most important library system in North America when it comes to branches.

“Due to that, we want to have the ability to present the companies to them right here on website as a result of that is the place they arrive.”


A safety guard watches as a person wheels his belongings right into a public library department in Toronto.


Brent Rose/International Information

He additionally factors out that solely a tiny fraction of visits to Toronto’s library branches flip violent.

“About 20 of our branches have excessive numbers of violent or disruptive incidents out of our 100. And of 9 and a half million visits, there have been about 300 that concerned a violent incident,” Daly says.

“However having stated that, in case you’re the one who is experiencing that incident as a employee or as a buyer of ours, even one incident is just too many.”


Brian Daly, chief human sources officer on the Toronto Public Library, describes the problem of preserving libraries secure.


Brent Rose/International Information

Toronto trains library workers on tips on how to take care of individuals who have skilled trauma.

Toronto additionally spends $3 million a yr on safety guards who’re assigned to 40 of the system’s 100 branches.

However Daly believes that’s just one piece of the puzzle.

“It’s not a matter of simply including increasingly more guards. That’s not the reply to this. We don’t need to create an setting the place folks really feel intimidated coming into our branches.”


Click to play video: 'Millennium Library reopening Monday with security measures'


Millennium Library reopening Monday with safety measures


Group Disaster Staff

Libraries throughout the nation are grappling with discovering a steadiness between supporting these with advanced wants and preserving all guests and workers secure.

The Edmonton Public Library acknowledged early on that there was a niche between the wants of a few of its extra susceptible shoppers and the companies the library was offering. So it introduced in individuals who had been most outfitted to assist: social staff. It was the primary library in Canada to take action.

The outreach staff are actually an important useful resource, connecting folks with the companies they want, corresponding to accessing info on the place to discover a shelter or a sizzling meal or tips on how to acquire an I.D. card.

“Folks began to be taught that the library was the place you may come for these helps. They may sit. They could possibly be snug. They had been welcomed,” says Sharon Day, the manager director of buyer expertise on the Edmonton Public Library.


Sharon Day, the director of buyer expertise on the Edmonton Public Library, talks about assembly the wants of all guests.


Sam Reid/International Information

Hilary Kirkpatrick is a social employee on the Edmonton Public Library. She says offering these companies works as a result of the area is accessible, shoppers are handled with respect they usually don’t really feel judged.

“We’re in a position to actually meet shoppers the place they’re at and serve their wants,” Kirkpatrick says.

Social staff have additionally change into an necessary a part of the group at different libraries together with Halifax, Calgary, Winnipeg and London.


Social employee Hilary Kirkpatrick of the Edmonton Public Library says she helps construct relationships by assembly the shoppers ‘the place they’re at’.


Sam Reid/International Information

Toronto is launching its personal pilot applications to assist susceptible guests. Along with connecting them with sources, they will even assist determine and take care of issues on the ground earlier than they escalate.

“These are social staff. These are people with psychological well being backgrounds who can are available and speak to people who’re in misery,” Daly says.

Toronto can be hiring six library security specialists who will work not solely with shoppers who need assistance, however with workers who are sometimes on the receiving finish of verbal or bodily assaults.

“More often than not it’s somebody who has been spit up, chewed up and spit out by society they usually’re on the finish of their rope,” Ray says.

Learn extra:

Laval police search shooter after gunfire at library leaves teen injured

He and McLeish imagine libraries want these sorts of applications as a result of librarians and workers aren’t at all times outfitted to deal with these doubtlessly unstable conditions.

“It’s so exhausting when you may’t really assist somebody,” Ray says. “As a lot as we might love to have the ability to have relationships with all these folks and assist them, we are able to’t as a result of I’m educated on Dewey Decimal.”

Stevenson has studied using social staff in libraries and seen firsthand the distinction they’ll make. However she worries they are going to be seen as a straightforward answer that may justify the additional dismantling of social applications.

“It’s a a lot greater coverage drawback,” she says.

The opioid disaster has additionally contributed to the rise in violence. The Toronto Public Library discovered a connection between the placement of the branches with essentially the most incidents and suspected opioid overdose hotspots within the metropolis.

“There’s loads of correlation with the type of challenges we’re experiencing extra broadly in society,” Daly says.

The Edmonton Public Library additionally noticed an uptick in drug-related incidents. “We noticed 99 poisonings in our branches in 2022, which is the largest distinction in what we might see pre-pandemic,” Day says.

Edmonton’s library system introduced in an opioid response group and added washroom attendants at its most affected branches.

Safety Measures

In response to the demise of Tyree Cayer, the Millennium Library in Winnipeg put in a steel detector and added a daily police presence.  It wasn’t the primary time guests had been checked on their approach in.

In 2019, handheld detectors had been used to display guests. However they had been eliminated one yr later after group teams protested they saved out the individuals who wanted library companies essentially the most.


Tyree Cayer, 28, was killed in an assault on the Millennium Library in Winnipeg.


Courtesy Tania Cayer

Tania Cayer, Tyree’s mom, feels the opposition to the additional safety measures is misplaced.

“Individuals who don’t work at that library, I don’t imagine ought to even have an opinion on whether or not a steel detector is put up or not,” she says. “It’s to maintain these folks secure.”

Tania doesn’t blame the library. She believes there are greater points at play.

“Winnipeg is battling youth crime. It’s battling medicine. There are one million and one points. This is only one of them.” she says.

Nonetheless, many libraries are in opposition to the addition of entrance obstacles due to the priority it should discourage susceptible shoppers from coming via their doorways.

“There are at all times going to be challenges if you’re in a public area coping with each type of particular person,” Day says. “The gorgeous factor about it’s that everyone’s welcome right here, but it surely’s additionally one of many exhausting issues about it as everyone’s welcome right here.”

The Library of the long run: group hub

If you happen to haven’t been to a public library recently, likelihood is you’ll be shocked by what you see. It’s not nearly books anymore.

Libraries are a mirror, reflecting folks in communities and their evolving wants. Meaning huge modifications at public libraries all over the place.

They’re continuously adapting to fulfill these new challenges, on the similar time, taking studying to a complete new stage, with 3-D printers, recording studios stuffed with devices, group kitchens —even locations to attempt the most recent video video games. There are broad open areas to calm down and research.

“Consider your group library, your native library … because the group’s lounge. A 3rd area. It’s not work. It’s not residence. It’s this different area,” Stevenson says.

A  library of the long run that appears nothing just like the library of the previous.

Leave a Reply