Skip to content

Truth or Fiction: Eli Holstein ought to get extra five-star consideration

Rivals nationwide recruiting director Adam Gorney and nationwide recruiting analyst Nick Harris together with Andrew Bone of and Jerit Roser of sort out three subjects and decide whether or not they consider every assertion is FACT or FICTION.


New gives from Alabama and LSU have altered Julian Sayin’s recruitment and the SEC powers will probably be critically thought of now.

Julian Sayin

Gorney’s take: FACT. Let’s wait and see what Arch Manning does as a result of if he picks Alabama it’s unlikely Julian Sayin or any elite 2024 quarterback will observe him to the identical college. I’ve been instructed Sayin is particularly going to take a a lot nearer take a look at LSU now with Texas, Georgia, Notre Dame and others nonetheless getting critical curiosity however there’s little question that if Alabama actually pushes for Sayin there will probably be mutual curiosity. The 2024 five-star is methodically going by the recruiting course of and now with Alabama and LSU gives, there could possibly be numerous modifications as to which group finally ends up on high.

Bone’s take: FACT. Alabama has established itself as a premier vacation spot for elite quarterbacks after the latest success on the place which has included a pair of first-round draft picks (Tua Tagovailoa, Mac Jones) and a Heisman Trophy winner (Bryce Younger). Tagovailoa and Jones had been additionally Heisman finalists. Sayin appears more likely to take a summer season go to swing to the SEC as he talked about being very intrigued by the supply from the Crimson Tide. A visit to Tuscaloosa, the chance to see every part Alabama has to supply and meet with the coaches will seemingly transfer the nationwide powerhouse into rivalry for the five-star recruit.


2. Eli Holstein ought to get extra five-star consideration within the rankings.

Eli Holstein

Eli Holstein (Nick Lucero/

Gorney’s take: FACT. Based mostly on stats alone, Eli Holstein ought to completely be within the five-star dialogue as a result of he threw for 29 touchdowns and rushed for 14 extra however everyone knows rankings aren’t based mostly on solely stats. Nonetheless, as we discuss a lot about Arch Manning and his vacation spot or Nico Iamaleava and his Tennessee dedication or how Malachi Nelson will slot in Lincoln Riley’s offense or whether or not Dante Moore will go to Notre Dame or head to the SEC, Holstein has been misplaced within the shuffle a bit bit. It’s greater than seemingly he finally ends up at Alabama, he’s an exceptional expertise and whereas having 5 five-star quarterbacks in a single class looks like lots, Holstein ought to undoubtedly be within the dialogue. An enormous summer season might assist much more.

Harris’ take: FICTION. Holstein is aptly rated as a excessive four-star prospect and because the No. 51 ranked recruit within the nation. That being mentioned, his potential to rise is way increased than arguably every other quarterback within the nation as he places collectively the items of an elite signal-caller forward of an vital Elite 11 camp and his senior season. Ought to he be a five-star within the new June rankings launch? Not fairly but. Do I believe he could make an argument at Elite 11 to place his identify among the many elite passers for the following rankings launch? Actually so. Contemplate it a giant proving floor for one in every of Louisiana’s finest.


3. Shelton Sampson has a busy summer season forward with numerous visits. He’ll nonetheless find yourself at LSU.

Shelton Sampson

Shelton Sampson (Sam Spiegelman)

Gorney’s take: FACT. Shelton Sampson shouldn’t be a lock to LSU as a result of Alabama is making a critical run and Florida State could possibly be a very sneaky risk as a result of he has so many connections to the Seminoles together with his former coach there now however high gamers from Louisiana usually go to LSU and the five-star receiver has been a precedence for a very long time. Coach Brian Kelly may not be the nearer right here as Sampson is tighter with others on workers however that’s completely fantastic and may work out effectively. If Dante Moore goes to LSU, that helps the Tigers’ possibilities much more. If he doesn’t, I nonetheless assume LSU is sitting fairly.

Roser’s take: FACT. I would not be shocked if Shelton Sampson Jr. finally ends up at any one in every of three or 4 applications. The SEC West trio of Alabama, LSU and Texas A&M have lengthy loomed the most important, and I would not overlook Florida State the place his former highschool coach Gabe Fertitta is now an analyst and one other Louisiana native, working backs coach David Johnson, has had success touchdown expertise from their residence state. However, if we’re betting now, I nonetheless assume the likeliest touchdown spot for the Baton Rouge Catholic receiver is simply three miles down the road. The hometown Tigers had been on Sampson early — which was clearly significant — and the brand new workers has continued to prioritize him. And it is a program he grew up admiring, the place he is spent extra time throughout his recruitment than any and has a robust pipeline from his highschool. I believe LSU survives a heated race for the gifted pass-catcher.

Leave a Reply

Powered by: sociorep