Physician Unusual 2’s Wanda Twist Performs On Her Worst Comics Tropes

What’s the Scarlet Witch’s sanity, if not tropes persevering?
Picture: John Byrne, Terry Austin, and Gaspar Saladino/Marvel Comics

In a medium the place long-lasting superhero characters have rollercoaster ups and downs over their careers, it’s a uncommon few which have had some downs fairly like the Scarlet Witch. Even ascendant as a part of the vanguard within the Marvel movieverse’s fourth part, her newest look in Physician Unusual within the Multiverse of Insanity disappointingly proves that identical to within the comics, placing Wanda on the alter of insanity is a trope her creatives simply can’t appear to wish to keep away from.

The shock “twist” of Physician Unusual within the Multiverse of Insanity—in a lot as one can actually have a twist 20 minutes right into a film that runs for an additional two hours past that—is that Elizabeth Olsen’s Wanda Maximoff isn’t the avenging ally Stephen Unusual thinks he’s getting when America Chavez multiversally lands on his proverbial doorstep. As a substitute, Wanda may be very a lot the villain of the piece, corrupted by each using the darkish magics of the Darkhold and by her personal psychological trauma, anguished by the lack of the sons she had conjured up for herself within the city of Westview, New Jersey—merchandise themselves created by Wanda’s additional grief over the lack of the person she liked, the synthezoid Imaginative and prescient.

Suffice to say, the response to her place because the MCU’s newest villain has been… blended, to say the least. After WandaVision offered her grief as each harmful and but considerably comprehensible—in a lot as one can perceive a reality-warping sorceress dominating a complete city of individuals in opposition to their will so she will play ‘50s housewife—Multiverse of Insanity catapults Wanda right into a horrifying villainous established order, an off-the-cuff assassin and unrelenting, unstoppable power that’s keen to do something for the prospect to get her kids again. The insanity of the film’s title is much less in regards to the cross-reality roadtrip Physician Unusual and his allies take to attempt to cease her, however Wanda herself, pushed to this unknown, horrible place, ever-framed as an unhinged and demented evil till the time comes for her to comprehend the scope of what she’s performed in her insanity, and be punished for it with self-sacrifice somewhat than rehabilitation.

Screenshot: Marvel Studios

Taking one of the vital highly effective, distinguished, and most beloved feminine figures in the MCU round at this level and making her flip heel irks, particularly within the wake of a (not solely spotless) try at a extra demure spin on Wanda’s grief in WandaVision. Nevertheless it’s not simply because she’s a fallen hero who’s given the tropey “feminine hero can’t deal with energy, goes mad within the course of” storyline, however as a result of it’s a trope that has outlined and influenced the Scarlet Witch for years, nicely earlier than she first acquired tailored into the Marvel Cinematic Universe. “Effectively, first off, it’s true to who the comics’ model of the character is and what she does within the comics,” Multiverse of Insanity and Loki author Michael Waldron mentioned of the choice to make Wanda the film’s massive dangerous in an interview with Rolling Stone this week. “It was all the time the place Wanda was headed within the MCU, whilst I inherited the film. The query simply grew to become, when would it not occur?”

That obvious inevitability Waldron believes—that Wanda Maximoff merely should change into this corrupted, maddened evil—is a shadow that’s chased the character throughout a long time of her comics historical past, and has now likewise been introduced into the MCU. From the times of her enthrallment beneath Cthon and the Darkhold’s powers at Mount Wundagore (which Multiverse of Insanity itself attracts on) within the pages of Avengers #187, all the best way as much as the notorious “No Extra Mutants” of Home of M—and that complicated mutant legacy that lingered past, now solely only recently starting to heal within the pages of Trial of Magnetotime and time once more Wanda’s story has turned to a darkish energy inside her, or in her attain, that transforms her not simply into one thing villainous, however a girl pushed to madness by her lack of ability to regulate it. And, most of the time, this has are available in tandem with forcing the character to confront the trauma of dropping her kids Billy and Tommy, and her husband the Imaginative and prescient.

Picture: John Byrne, Paul Ryan, Invoice Oakley, and Bob Sharen/Marvel Comics

We first actually see this in “Darker than Scarlet,” within the pages of 1990’s West Coast Avengers #56, when Wanda, corrupted right into a villainous model of herself by her father Magneto, lashes out at her former allies in vegeance for the lack of her household—it’s telling that the difficulty opens with the captured Agatha Harkness, U.S. Agent, Wasp, and Surprise Man all reflecting on Wanda having gone insane along with her grief, and much more in order that that is the story the place we first be taught that Wanda’s hex powers don’t alter likelihood, however warp actuality itself. Time and time once more, the connection between the scope of Wanda’s superpower and her obvious lack of willpower to regulate it’s made all through the bottom factors of her life within the comics, pressured perpetually to re-confront the trauma of dropping Billy and Tommy. It infamously occurs a long time later in 2004’s Avengers Disassembled, with Agatha Harkness’ equally notorious manner of retaining Wanda docile—erasing her reminiscence of her kids—breaks down, and Wanda seemingly, merely, can’t assist however mentally unravel and switch to evil as soon as extra.

After which, after all, there’s probably the most well-known of all, Home of M only a 12 months later, when Wanda rouses in response to the gathered X-Males and Avengers looking for to cease her harmful madness, and warps all of actuality to create an idealized world the place she all the time had her kids by her facet. Though outwardly right here Wanda is appearing much less on a villainous impulse than she is an awesome plot system, Home of M nonetheless concludes with one in all her most horrifying acts within the comics, the almost-extermination of the mutant race when she de-powers all however roughly 200 of the species—a darkness that has solely actually simply begun to be addressed within the present Krakoan period of X-comics. And even then, Wanda (who, because of cinematic-ambition-induced retcons, is not a mutant nowadays) had up till Trial of Magneto been seen as a metaphysical boogeywoman for the resurgent mutantkind, the “Nice Pretender” who tried to put their species low.

Picture: Joe Quesada/Marvel Comics

Energy and Wanda’s obvious capability for evil have gone hand in hand throughout generations of tales for the character, decreasing one of the vital distinguished feminine Avengers of the staff’s complete existence time and time once more to a deranged being to be confronted and managed, out of concern that her powers will hurt greater than assist. And now, with Multiverse of Insanity, the MCU has turned to that very same nicely with its personal model of Wanda Maximoff. However did it actually need to? Did it must when WandaVision earlier than it, in participating with that concept itself, managed to current a Scarlet Witch that was, on the very least, extra understandably sympathetic as an alternative of the bloodthirsty villain we’re confronted with in Multiverse of Insanity?

Time will inform simply how the MCU appears upon the Scarlet Witch going ahead—even when Multiverse of Insanity ends her arc with a seeming sacrifice, loss of life (obvious or in any other case) is never everlasting on the planet of superhero movies. However whether or not the MCU tries to push Wanda on a rehabilitative path, a query will all the time linger for followers of her as a personality: does it actually all the time need to be this manner?


Need extra io9 information? Take a look at when to anticipate the newest Marvel and Star Wars releases, what’s subsequent for the DC Universe on movie and TV, and all the things it’s worthwhile to learn about Home of the Dragon and Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Energy.

Leave a Reply